Performance management ... for some, the term brings up memories of awkward year-end reviews, vague rating systems, and goals no one looked at after February. For others, it feels like a buzzword—something HR does behind closed doors.
When done right, performance management is one of the most powerful tools an organisation can use to build high-performing, engaged, and aligned teams.
So, what exactly is performance management in teams? And why does it so often fall flat?
Performance management is the ongoing process of aligning individual and team goals with organisational objectives, tracking progress, giving feedback, and enabling development.
It’s not a once-a-year form. It’s a rhythm. A culture. A system of working together intentionally to grow, course-correct, and succeed.
In a team context, performance management involves several core components:
Goal setting
Clear, shared, and measurable goals that every team member understands and is working toward.
Regular check-ins
Frequent conversations (weekly or monthly) between team members and their manager to discuss progress, blockers, and support needed.
Feedback culture
Encouraging open, constructive feedback—not just top-down, but peer-to-peer and bottom-up.
Performance reviews
Formal evaluations, ideally grounded in data and observed behaviours, not just opinions or outcomes.
Development planning
Looking beyond what someone did to what they could do next. Supporting learning and growth.
Recognition and reward
Acknowledging effort, progress, and results—celebrating wins and motivating people to keep growing.
Why is it often ineffective?
Despite the good intentions, performance management often misses the mark. Here are some reasons why:
Lack of consistency: Reviews are rushed or skipped. Goals are set and forgotten.
One-size-fits-all: Standard forms don’t capture team dynamics or individual contributions.
Poor feedback: Feedback is vague, too late, or avoided altogether.
Fear-based culture: Performance conversations feel punitive instead of developmental.
Focus only on outcomes: Results matter—but so do behaviours, collaboration, and effort.
Manager skills gap: Many managers are not trained to coach, give feedback, or handle difficult conversations.
The result? People disengage. High performers feel unrecognised. Struggling team members feel unsupported. Teams drift instead of driving performance.
How can it be done right?
To make performance management effective and empowering in teams, consider the following:
Start with trust
Teams perform when they feel psychologically safe. Foster open conversations. Make feedback normal and helpful, not personal or punitive.
Make it continuous
Move away from annual reviews as the only formal touchpoint. Create a rhythm of ongoing feedback, reflection, and progress updates.
Tailor to the team
Consider team dynamics, collaboration, and shared goals—not just individual performance. Look at how the team functions together.
Use the right metrics
Blend quantitative (e.g. delivery targets) with qualitative (e.g. team contribution, initiative, collaboration).
Build manager capability
Train managers to coach, not just evaluate. They should know how to ask great questions, listen actively, and develop their people.
Link to development, not just results
Help people grow from feedback—not just "rate" them. Build a culture where learning is valued as much as achievement.
Celebrate the wins
Recognition matters. Don’t wait until year-end to show appreciation. Celebrate small and big wins alike to build momentum and morale.
Performance management isn’t just about assessing performance—it’s about enabling it.
When teams are clear on goals, supported with feedback, and led by managers who care about their growth, performance becomes a shared mission—not a dreaded meeting.
The challenge is not just to measure performance, but to ignite it.
And that starts with a shift—from process to people. From evaluation to development. From compliance to commitment.
Share this post
Newsletter
Get up-to-date industry news right in your inbox
